Popular Hotels in Shelter Island Heights 2025

• 

  The Chequit

  0.0 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  The Chequit Inn

  HOTEL

  From $211.48

  0.1 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  House on Chase Creek

  From $105.00

  0.2 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  Dering Harbor Inn, Shelter Island Heights

  HOTEL

  0.5 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  West Neck Guesthouse

  0.6 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House, Shelter Island Heights

  HOTEL

  From $277.20

  0.8 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island

  From $297.00

  0.8 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  Shelter Island House

  From $175.00

  0.8 mile from Center

  Get Details
• 

  Ram's Head Inn

  From $135.00

  3.2 mile from Center

  Get Details